Community June 27, 2018

The Yellow Card

A Way To Improve All Sports

The greatest thing about the World Cup is its name and scope of participation. There is no “world” in baseball or American football, even hockey or basketball, although basketball is making a claim for it on the professional level. But the world does participate in soccer as a player or fan. The only true world sport.

From my perspective it is the most civilized team sport on the planet. To others it is too slow and too low scoring. Unlike basketball, the entire team is not involved all the time. But I guess that depends on what “involved” means.

Shockingly, soccer has only one referee and two assistant referees formerly known as linesmen. One at each end to determine if the ball is out of bounds or the players are off sides. The rules of the game are understood by everyone—nothing new there—but the players have a quality of self-enforcement you don’t see in other sports. I’m not saying there is no pushing and shoving, tripping, I’m saying players don’t argue with the referee or challenge a call as it done in other major sports. Egregiously. When this happens to excess in soccer, the referee can issue a Yellow Card, a warning for everyone to see. Then next infraction in the same game by the same player results in a Red Card and the player is ejected. The player can object but has no appeal and he or she can’t get in the face of the referee as they do in American football. Even that infraction—a lack of respect—can earn a second yellow card: the red card. And here is the beauty—there is no substitution allowed for the ejected player—the team then needs to play with one less player. And the yellow card infraction carries over to the next game.

There is no such thing in other sports: basketball players can play at the yellow-card level for four more times before being “ejected.” They can’t be replaced. They can’t be taken out of the game to cool down after their first foul as happens in other sports. That kind of substitution is not permitted in soccer. In American football egregious fouls result is a 15-yard penalty against the team. The individual is not punished

Finally—although there is no such word when discussing sports—it is the only global sport that requires a player to play for the country where he was born. For example, Lionel Messi, pictured above, is the greatest player of his era, plays for Barcelona for his paycheck, but plays for Argentina in the World Cup. The pressure to perform for country is greater than playing for local fans. It’s unique to soccer.

So join several 100 million who will be watching the World Cup finals in the next few days and be a global sports fan for a while. It will take your mind off whatshisname!

5 Comments

  • July 3, 2018

    Love the crow giving a yellow card!

  • July 5, 2018

    I had three teenage soccer boys over for the 4th. The reminded me that if you get a yellow card you will not play in the next game. Why? Because the yellow card carries over to the next game and the risk of a second yellow–or red–is to great. The team can not substitute for someone who gets a red card so they would continue play minus one player. That is not worth the risk!

  • July 8, 2018

    Sport crossover: The article suggests that other sports can learn from soccer’s use of the red & yellow card and why not. Perhaps one factor that will determine the “take up” is the degree to which a particular sport is managed/governed by dinosaurs or progressives? Traditionally, soccer has been administered by dinosaurs, and that’s before we get into corruption & Sepp Blatter. This world cup is the first to use VAR, i.e. the use of video technology to support the match officials in “contentious” decisions and certainly strongly linked with the use of Red & Yellow cards in crucial moments of a game. The fact that other sports such as tennis have been using their own VAR equivalents for many years now is a good indication of the slow pace of change in the corridors of soccer power such as FIFA & UEFA

  • July 8, 2018

    I am fully confident that there is corruption in all sports. The Yellow Card just brings some veracity to the idea sportsmanship and accountability. Meanwhile, if you saw the Russia vs. Croatia shootout on Saturday, as my daughter did for the first time, predicting the outcome is great sport. None have a better analysis and guide than these folks: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/a-chart-for-predicting-penalty-shootout-odds-in-real-time/

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our Greek Chorus
Opinions of The Vigilant
The Greek chorus was an integral part of ancient Greek theatre, a group of three or four performers who looked alike and spoke all at the same time. Their part was to comment on what was being said and help the audience know what the characters in the play were thinking. The chorus usually sang, or spoke. We honor that tradition here
Christiano Ronaldo
Surprises a kid
On the streets of Madrid
Updated Posts

He’s a trickster, a conman, out to fool you and win at all costs, sparing no deception.

by Josh Hammond

What’s the Stink About?

by Josh Hammond

Zuckerberg Puts on Angel Face

by Josh Hammond
Our Newsletter
The easiest way for you to stay on top of what’s happening at Free American News is subscribe to our weekly update. Out every Friday morning, bright and early, it lists the latest post and has some exclusive extras. Please use the pop-up subscription form or click on the subscribe to newsletter box on the lower right-hand column.
Go to the Newsletter Subscription page